As discovered on Ancestry.com, two descendants from Allen Etherton, b1850 or Sarah Jane Lipe, b1854, share DNA.
Predicted Relationship: 1st-2nd cousin
Actual Relationship: 1st cousin, once removed
Shared DNA: 436 cM across 17 segments
Path A: Allen & Sarah Etherton -> Martha Jane Etherton, b1886 -> Norman Virgil Pirtle, b1919 -> Ancestry.com user Joni Pirtle.
Path B: Allen & Sarah Etherton -> Willis Allen Etherton, b1895 -> Ancestry user Gordon Etherton